Checklist · 12 picks · 4 categories
Links to Amazon are affiliate links. I earn a commission if you buy, at no cost to you, and it never decides a pick. How I make money
Affiliate link.
A great bed is built in layers, and you don't need a new mattress to get one. Start with a topper: HGTV's testers slept on most of theirs for over a year and found picks that soften a firm or hand-me-down mattress, from a washable pillow-top to a 3-inch memory foam slab.
Next comes a waterproof protector, the cheapest insurance your mattress will ever get; TechGearLab poured wine on its picks to see which ones held. Then the comfy part: pillows from Reviewed, queen sheets from BestReviews and a comforter you can toss in the wash. Order matters too, so put the topper on first, the protector over it, then the sheets. Each card shows the drawback its outlet called out, so you know what you're signing up for before you hit buy.
Who this is not for. Skip this if your bed is fine and the problem is light, noise or a racing brain; the Better Sleep list has sound machines, sleep masks and blackout curtains.
Tell me what you can spend. I pick a tier for every item, essentials first, and show what is left. The first amount covers everything you need at the cheapest tier.
Pick a budget to see your plan.
Your plan lives in this link. Copy it or email it to yourself so Safari doesn't forget it.
Estimates based on typical prices, checked Oct 31, 2026. Prices change; see the store for today's price.
0 of 4 on your list · tap one to see your options
| Pick | Tier | Price | Best for | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leisure Town Pillow-Top Washable Mattress Topper | budget | $25-50 | softening a firm or hand-me-down mattress for cheap | 1 outlet |
| Best Price Mattress Memory Foam Mattress Topper | mid | $100-150 | memory foam feel without the memory foam price | 1 outlet |
| Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme | splurge | $200-300 | a cloud-soft upgrade for an old innerspring mattress | 1 outlet |
| Linenspa 5-Sided Waterproof Mattress Protector | budget | $15-25 | spill-proofing a new mattress for cheap | 1 outlet |
| PlushDeluxe Premium Bamboo Mattress Protector | mid | $25-50 | a protector that adds a little cushion | 1 outlet |
| SureGuard Waterproof Hypoallergenic Mattress Protector | mid | $25-50 | deep mattresses and sweaty summer nights | 1 outlet |
Best mattress topperbudget pick · 8 sizes, Twin XL included
Best for softening a firm or hand-me-down mattress for cheap
HGTV's best for dorms and college apartments: adds softness and cushion to a firm mattress without breaking the bank, and the whole thing goes in the washer.
1 outlet. HGTV best for Dorms and College Apartments.
$25-50
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link. I may earn a commission at no cost to you.
mid pick · Twin to California King
Best for memory foam feel without the memory foam price
HGTV's best budget mattress topper: memory foam comfort on a tighter budget, and it molded to its tester's body and softened a firm innerspring mattress.
Heads up. Had a subtle smell for the first few days and took longer to expand, and HGTV suggests the 3-inch over the 4-inch
1 outlet. HGTV best Budget mattress topper.
$100-150
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
splurge pick · 3 in
Best for a cloud-soft upgrade for an old innerspring mattress
HGTV's best memory foam mattress topper: just the right amount of softness without making you feel like you're sinking.
Heads up. It can't be returned, per HGTV, and needs a day or so to air out
1 outlet. HGTV best Memory Foam Mattress Topper.
$200-300
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
Best mattress protectorbudget pick · Pick by bed
Best for spill-proofing a new mattress for cheap
TechGearLab's best overall mattress protector: reliable protection against daily mishaps, and it passed its wine spill test with flying colors.
Heads up. Not the most breathable, and there's no cushion on top
1 outlet. TechGearLab best overall mattress protector.
$15-25
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
mid pick · Pick by bed
Best for a protector that adds a little cushion
TechGearLab's best bamboo protector: a comfy, cushioned top with a polyurethane backing for spill protection, and testers heard no sound from it.
Heads up. Takes a long time to dry, and the elastic and sides are weaker
1 outlet. TechGearLab best bamboo protector.
$25-50
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
mid pick · Pick by bed
Best for deep mattresses and sweaty summer nights
TechGearLab's best for breathability: a soft cotton terry top that helps absorb and evaporate sweat, with a polyurethane backing underneath.
Heads up. Stains easily, and the elastic is a bit weak
1 outlet. TechGearLab best for Breathability mattress protector.
$25-50
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
Best pillowmid pick · Pick by bed
Best for finding your perfect height
Reviewed's best pillow overall: adjustable fill so you can make it firmer or softer, and it's washable.
Heads up. Takes some fill tinkering, and it needs to air out at first
2 outlets agree. Reviewed best pillow overall. Business Insider top 10 college gift.
$50-100
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
budget pick · Pick by bed
Best for replacing flat pillows on a budget
Reviewed's best value pillow: affordable, washable, and it didn't smell out of the box.
Heads up. May not be lofty enough for some side sleepers
1 outlet. Reviewed best value pillow.
$25-50
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
Best sheetsbudget pick · Queen
Best for cheap, soft sheets that skip the ironing
BestReviews' best bang for the buck queen sheet set: soft brushed microfiber that stays true to color, with deep pockets that fit even pillow-top mattresses.
Heads up. Thin material that can rip, per BestReviews
1 outlet. BestReviews best bang for the buck queen sheet set.
$25-50
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
mid pick · Queen
Best for two people who sleep hot
BestReviews' best of the best queen sheet set: 300-thread-count bamboo viscose that's moisture-wicking and soft to keep you cool at night.
Heads up. The material may not be very durable, per BestReviews
1 outlet. BestReviews best of the best queen sheet set.
$50-100
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
Best comforterbudget pick · Twin to California King
Best for a fluffy bed refresh for less
Reviewed's best overall comforter: a soft, affordable pick that's easy to clean.
Heads up. The stitching is low quality, and the color doesn't match the online photo
1 outlet. Reviewed best Overall comforter.
$25-50
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
mid pick · Queen or King
Best for swapping between a light and a fluffy bed
Reviewed's most versatile comforter: a two-layer set that works across seasons and is easy to wash.
Heads up. Reviewed couldn't find a drawback for this one, so check the sizes on the listing
1 outlet. Reviewed most versatile comforter.
$50-100
Shop on AmazonAffiliate link.
means three independent outlets recommend a pick, means one, and limited evidence means none has yet. I research these picks. I have not tested them myself. How I pick · Broken link, wrong price range or an outdated pick? Tell me
HGTV says toppers simply rest on top of the mattress and most are held in place by your fitted sheet, and that a protector works on its own or in combination with a topper. Put the topper on the mattress, the protector over both, then the fitted sheet. Check that your sheets' pockets are deep enough for the extra height.
Per HGTV, a topper is mostly about comfort and is usually at least an inch or two tall, a pad adds only a thin layer of padding, and a protector adds no comfort but guards against spills, dust and bedbugs.
HGTV's testers liked 3 inches: the TEMPUR-Topper Supreme is 3 inches and still easy to get a fitted sheet over, and they found the 4-inch Best Price topper a little too high, so they suggest the 3-inch version. If your mattress is already tall, HGTV says a 2- to 3-inch topper is the safer bet.