Ninja Creami vs Cuisinart FastFreeze

Creami for presets and big batches; FastFreeze for small spaces.

From two side-by-side reviews: NBC Select and Taste of Home. I haven't used either. The Amazon buttons are affiliate links: I get a commission if you buy, at no cost to you.

Slight edge Illustration: frozen treat machine

Ninja Creami

Best for presets and big batches

Ninja Creami NC301

Get it if you want the most presets and customization and can handle the noise.

See Ninja Creami on Amazon
Illustration: ice cream maker

Cuisinart FastFreeze

Best for small spaces

Cuisinart FastFreeze Ice Cream Maker

Get it if you have small space, such as a first apartment, and want to spend less.

See Cuisinart FastFreeze on Amazon

The short answer

Slight edge: Ninja Creami

NBC Select ranks the Creami first overall and the FastFreeze a very close second. Choose the Creami for versatility and presets; choose the FastFreeze for a smaller, cheaper machine if you do not mind pushing the handle.

In the Facebook or Instagram app, Amazon may open signed out: sign in there to check out as usual.

How they differ

Ninja CreamiCuisinart FastFreeze
TextureCreamy and smooth, closest to store-boughtAlmost identical in the author's results; some colleagues preferred it
Effort and noiseLoud, about like a blender or vacuum; about 10 minutes of mixing after a day of freezingMixes quickly but you push a handle up and down by hand
Size and weightAbout 13 lbAbout 4.4 lb; much more compact Edge
Presets7 presets plus re-spin Edge5 presets
Heads upLoud, and the mix needs a day in the freezer firstYou pump the handle by hand, and the blade is tricky to clean
Tier and where we list itSplurge tier. On Homemade Ice Cream Starter Kit, Bridal Shower Gifts, Gifts for Tweens.Not on our lists yet.
See today's priceNinja Creami on Amazon Cuisinart FastFreeze on Amazon

Edge marks a row where the review clearly favors that side.

A second opinion from Taste of Home

Sources: NBC Select. Updated July 2026; Creami first overall, Cuisinart FastFreeze a very close second. Taste of Home. Feb 18, 2026, by Barbara Bellesi Zito with testers Annamarie Higley and Emily Way: used the Creami XL Deluxe and the FastFreeze, and recommends both, the Creami for frequent big batches and the FastFreeze for small spaces and single servings. Check the current price on Amazon before you buy.

Questions

How far ahead do you need to start?

Both freeze a base first. NBC Select describes about 10 minutes of Creami mixing after a day of freezing, and Taste of Home says 24 hours is recommended for the Creami base, though one tester's froze in 15 hours in a very cold freezer.

Where do you store them?

Taste of Home says the FastFreeze is compact enough to fit in a drawer, while the tall Creami is hard to store in small spaces.

Can you add mix-ins to the FastFreeze?

Yes, but Taste of Home says not to overfill with large add-ins, and that using slightly less cream and milk helps.

Ready to pick?

Ninja Creami for presets and big batches

See Ninja Creami on Amazon

Cuisinart FastFreeze for small spaces

See Cuisinart FastFreeze on Amazon

Still not sure? See every pick on Gifts for Tweens

More comparisons

I get a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no cost to you. It never decides a pick. How I make money