Checklist · 12 picks + 5 nice to have · 3 categories

Gifts for true crime fans

I get a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no cost to you. It never decides a pick. How I make money

True crime fans love a puzzle, a good story and a reason to talk about both. She's Birdie's personal safety alarm leads because three outlets back it, PureWow among them, and it suits anyone who gets jumpy after a podcast marathon.

Read moreRead less

PureWow also picks Unsolved Case Files for playing detective at home, and TODAY's editors love I'll Be Gone in the Dark. Tip: skip anything that makes light of real victims; games and well-reported books are the safer gifts.

Who this is not for. If they prefer fictional monsters and haunted houses to real cases, try the horror fans list instead.

In the Facebook or Instagram app, Amazon may open signed out: sign in there to check out as usual.

Showing all 12 picks

More filters

Budget, Mid and Splurge are this list's cheaper, middle and pricier picks.

01 Cozy and Gear

Compare these 4
PickTierBest forEvidence
She's Birdie Personal Safety Alarmmidrunners and travelers1 outlet
Evidence Zipper Pouchbudgeta small stocking stuffer1 outlet
Master Lock Door Security Barmidtravelers and renters1 outlet
This is My True Crime Watching Blanketmidbinge-watching nightsLimited evidence

mid safety alarm · Keychain

She's Birdie Personal Safety Alarm

Best for runners and travelers

A keychain alarm with a loud siren and a strobe light. NBC Select calls it an editor's pick safety keychain, and People lists it among its best gift ideas for women.

Picked by NBC Select top pick. Heads up and sources

Heads up. NBC Select says it can malfunction: its reviewer's once turned on without being activated

Mid pick

Shop on Amazon

budget zipper pouch · 7.25 x 9.5 inches

Evidence Zipper Pouch

Best for a small stocking stuffer

A Blue Q zipper pouch with an evidence theme, 7.25 by 9.5 inches and made of 95 percent recycled plastic. Handy for makeup, cords or pens.

Picked by Mental Floss. Sources

Budget pick

Shop on Amazon

mid blanket · 50 x 65 inches

This is My True Crime Watching Blanket

Best for binge-watching nights

A blanket with the line This is My True Crime Watching Blanket. For the fan who has a documentary queued up every night.

My pick. I haven't found a review naming it yet.

Mid pick

Shop on Amazon

02 Books and Calendars

Compare these 3
PickTierBest forEvidence
A Year of True Crime Page-a-Day Calendarbudgetdaily true crime reading1 outlet
I'll Be Gone in the Darkbudgetserious true crime readers1 outlet
Stay Sexy & Don't Get Murdered: The Definitive How-To GuidebudgetMy Favorite Murder listeners1 outlet

03 Games and Puzzles

Compare these 5
PickTierBest forEvidence
Unsolved Case Files: Cold Case Murder Mysterymidwannabe detectivesLimited evidence
At Home Murder Mystery: On The High Seas Editionsplurgehosting a murder mystery night1 outlet
Hasbro Clue Board Gamebudgeta low-cost classic1 outlet
Cold Case Puzzlesbudgeta stocking stuffer1 outlet
Brain Games: Criminal Mind Puzzlesbudgetsolo puzzle fansLimited evidence

budget puzzle book · 100 puzzles

Cold Case Puzzles

Best for a stocking stuffer

Cheapism's true crime gift guide lists this spiral-bound Brain Games book of 100 plus crime-themed brain teasers. An easy stocking stuffer for puzzle people.

Picked by Cheapism. Sources

Budget pick

Shop on Amazon

budget puzzle book · 120 puzzles

Brain Games: Criminal Mind Puzzles

Best for solo puzzle fans

A Brain Games puzzle book of crime-themed puzzles to test your detective skills. Made for solo puzzle fans who like a case to crack.

My pick. I haven't found a review naming it yet.

Budget pick

Shop on Amazon
See 5 more picks

mid mystery game · 1 to 5 players

Death at The Dive Bar

Best for small groups or solo sleuths

Cheapism's true crime gift guide includes this Hunt A Killer game, where you decode ciphers and sort clues to name the killer. For 1 to 5 players, up to an hour.

Picked by Cheapism. Sources

Mid pick

Shop on Amazon

means three independent outlets recommend a pick, means one, and limited evidence means none has yet. I research these picks. I have not tested them myself. How I pick · Spot a mistake? A broken link, a wrong price range or an outdated pick: tell me at hello@allsetlist.com and I'll fix it.

Side by side

Questions people ask

What is the best gift for someone who loves true crime podcasts?

TODAY's guide suggests books by podcast hosts, like Ashley Flowers's All Good People Here and the My Favorite Murder hosts' Stay Sexy and Don't Get Murdered. A cold case game is a good pick if they would rather play than read.

Are there true crime gifts that do not make light of real victims?

Yes. I stuck to games, puzzles, well-known nonfiction and practical gear. I left out novelty items that treat real cases as a joke.

What can I give a group of true crime friends?

A murder mystery game is the easiest. TODAY lists Unsolved Case Files for up to 8 players, and At Home Murder Mystery: On The High Seas Edition for up to 13 players.

Do personal safety gifts make sense for true crime fans?

PureWow and TODAY both pick the She's Birdie alarm, and PureWow also picks the Master Lock Door Security Bar for people who feel uneasy after a podcast. They are practical rather than scary.

When should I order so it arrives by Christmas?

USPS's recommended last send dates for December 25 in the contiguous US are December 17 for Ground Advantage, December 18 for Priority Mail and December 19 for Priority Mail Express. Retailers set their own order-by dates, so check at checkout.

Know someone shopping for this? Send them the list.

Text it Email it

Three emails before Christmas, then I leave you alone.

Nov 25: the Black Friday shortlist. Dec 14: the shipping cutoffs. Dec 21: the last-minute list. Gift ideas only, no price tracking. Unsubscribe in one click.

I will use your email only for this. See the privacy page.

Buy my list

I get a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no cost to you. It never decides a pick. How I make money