Toniebox 2 vs Original Toniebox

Toniebox 2 for first-time buyers; original on a deal.

From two side-by-side reviews: The Strategist and MadeForMums. I haven't used either. The Amazon buttons are affiliate links: I get a commission if you buy, at no cost to you.

The pick Illustration: audio player

Toniebox 2

Best for first-time buyers

Tonies Toniebox 2 Starter Set

Get it if you're buying a first Toniebox, especially for a child from 12 months, and want the bedtime features.

See Toniebox 2 on Amazon
Illustration: audio player

Original Toniebox

Best for a bundle deal

Tonies Playtime Puppy Toniebox Starter Set

Get it if you find a good bundle deal and don't need games or sleep features.

See Original Toniebox on Amazon

The short answer

The pick: Toniebox 2

The Strategist's tester, whose toddler used the original first, says first-time buyers should get the Toniebox 2: it starts at 12 months instead of 3 years, has four times the storage, charges by USB-C and adds a sunrise alarm, sleep timer and Tonieplay games. The original is still a good gift at a good bundle price, and families who already own one don't need to upgrade unless they want the games.

In the Facebook or Instagram app, Amazon may open signed out: sign in there to check out as usual.

How they differ

Toniebox 2Original Toniebox
Starting age12 months Edge3 years
Storage32GB Edge8GB
ChargingUSB-C, with a very short cord EdgeCharging station
GamesTonieplay games (controller and games sold separately) EdgeNone
BedtimeSunrise alarm, sleep timer and light ring EdgeNone
Tonies figuresAll work, including My First ToniesAll work
ControlsSqueeze the ears, tap and tiltThe same
Tier and where we list itNot on our lists yet.Mid tier. On Gifts for Kids.
See today's priceToniebox 2 on Amazon Original Toniebox on Amazon

Edge marks a row where the review clearly favors that side.

A second opinion from MadeForMums

Sources: The Strategist. Oct 14, 2025, by Liza Corsillo, who reviewed the Toniebox 2 with her toddler after using the original: get the new one unless the old one is a bargain. MadeForMums. Sep 15, 2025, by Joanna Magill, feature by feature: the Toniebox 2 is worth upgrading to, mainly for the Tonieplay games. Check the current price on Amazon before you buy.

Questions

Do my old Tonies work on the Toniebox 2?

Yes. The Strategist says every figure works on both boxes, but the Tonieplay games only work on the Toniebox 2.

Does the Toniebox 2 have a headphone jack?

No. The Strategist lists the missing headphone jack as one of its drawbacks.

Ready to pick?

Toniebox 2 for first-time buyers

See Toniebox 2 on Amazon

Original Toniebox for a bundle deal

See Original Toniebox on Amazon

Still not sure? See every pick on Gifts for Kids

More comparisons

I get a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no cost to you. It never decides a pick. How I make money